The Pretty Lie vs The Ugly Truth: What We Owe Each Other in Grief

There’s a tension in grief we don’t talk about enough -the moment where we choose between the pretty lie and the ugly truth.

It’s a choice most of us make instinctively. When someone is grieving - or when we are - we feel a powerful pull to soften things, to shield, to wrap reality in something gentler.

Sometimes it comes from love.

Sometimes from fear.

Sometimes from our own discomfort.

We do it because the truth feels too sharp to hand over bare.

The pretty lie is tempting.

It glitters.

It feels like protection.

It buys time.

It sounds like:

“It wasn’t that bad.”

“They didn’t feel pain.”

“You’re so strong - you’ll get through this.”

“Everything happens for a reason.”

It floats like a bubble - light, shimmering, fragile.

But all bubbles eventually pop.

And when they do, the truth arrives all at once - unsoftened, unfiltered, uncompromising.

The truth doesn’t wait for the right time.

It comes when it comes.

This is where so many secondary wounds begin.

Because no matter which path you choose - the pretty lie or the ugly truth - the other path will always be questioned later.

If you speak the truth early, you might hear:

“Why couldn’t you let me believe the softer version for a little longer?”

If you offer the pretty lie first, someone may ask:“

Why didn’t you tell me the truth?”

There is no perfect choice.

There is only the one we make with the capacity we have in the moment.

And often, the choice has more to do with us than with them:

We delay truth because:

• we fear their reaction

• we fear witnessing pain

• we fear the silence that follows honesty

• we fear the responsibility that comes with naming what is real

• 
  

Grief makes truth feel heavier.

Death makes truth feel radioactive - fragile and explosive at the same time.

It becomes easy to soften reality, to make loss more palatable, to protect others from what is already true.

But the truth does not become less true just because we delay it.

And delayed truth carries its own shadow: confusion, resentment, and the sense that something essential was kept from them.

There are situations where the level of information needs to shift - especially when speaking to children - but shifting the level of detail is different from hiding reality.

Children do not benefit from metaphors or euphemisms like:

• “went to sleep”

• “passed on”

• “became an angel”

These phrases often create confusion, fear around sleep, or misunderstandings that linger.

What children need is:

• clear, direct language

• spoken simply

• without technical terms

• and without unnecessary, overwhelming detail

• 
  

The truth can be offered plainly, gently, and age-appropriately -but still honestly.

It is not about sugar-coating.

It is about clarity without causing harm.

The question, then, is not:

“Pretty lie or ugly truth?”

It is:

“What are we trying to protect - and at what cost?”

Because truth has its own kind of mercy.

Not because it’s soft, but because it’s solid.

It gives people something real to stand on.

Pretty lies lift us temporarily.

But when the bubble bursts, the fall can be harder.

In grief - and in life - the most compassionate path is rarely the easiest one.

Truth requires presence, courage, and a willingness to stay with someone as they meet it.

The truth may not be pretty.

But it is trustworthy.

And sometimes the deepest kindness we can offer is this:

To tell the truth with tenderness, and sit beside someone as they face it.